Aug. 04, 2025
Dividing Executive Compensation and Stock Options in a North Carolina Divorce
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, nearly 10% of all private-sector employees receive some form of stock option or equity compensation, and in tech and biotech fields, the numbers are even higher. When divorce occurs, those options and restricted shares can represent a lifetime’s worth of financial security—or a devastating loss if not divided correctly. If you’re in Greensboro and facing these questions, don’t underestimate what’s at stake.
The law firm of Mercedes O. Chut, P.A. helps clients throughout North Carolina approach these issues with clear strategy, strong advocacy, and a deep understanding of the law.
What Counts as Marital Property?
North Carolina is an “equitable distribution” state. That means most property acquired during the marriage—regardless of whose name is on the title—belongs to both spouses. But executive compensation is rarely a simple line item on a tax return. You need to ask:
-
- When were the options or shares granted?
- What was the compensation for? Past, present, or future work?
- Are the awards vested, partially vested, or completely unvested?
- Do they have restrictions or performance triggers?
The timing and purpose of each grant make a critical difference. For example, stock options granted for work performed during the marriage—even if they vest after the divorce is filed—are usually considered marital property, at least in part (Wade v. Wade, 72 N.C. App. 372). By contrast, options awarded for future service, or as a signing bonus after separation, may be classified as separate property. This distinction is one of the most litigated issues in high-net-worth North Carolina divorces.
A top-rated divorce attorney in Greensboro, NC will analyze employment contracts, grant letters, and benefit plan documents to uncover every potential asset. Overlooking even one detail could mean leaving substantial money on the table.
How Do You Value Stock Options and Restricted Stock?
Valuation is where things get technical—and contentious. Unlike cash or real estate, executive compensation often hinges on future events. Courts typically apply the “coverture fraction” method to separate marital and nonmarital portions. Here’s an example:
Suppose you were granted 2,000 stock options in year one of a four-year marriage, with options vesting over four years. If the marriage lasts two years, then 50% of the options are marital, because they were “earned” during the marriage.
But what is each option actually worth? The answer depends on:
- The current stock price versus the strike price
- The company’s growth prospects
- Vesting schedules and forfeiture risks
- Potential tax consequences
- Company policies about transferability or “cash outs” after divorce
Accurate valuation often requires expert analysis—sometimes even a forensic accountant or a financial planner familiar with executive compensation. A Greensboro divorce attorney with experience in these matters will work closely with experts to ensure a fair outcome.
Can the Court Force a Company to Divide Stock Options?
No, a North Carolina judge can order your spouse’s employer to split a single option or grant you shares directly if the company plan doesn’t allow it. Instead, courts may order the employee spouse to transfer a proportional share when (and if) the options vest or the stocks become available. This is called a “deferred distribution order.” For privately held companies, the process can get even more nuanced—sometimes requiring creative solutions, like offsetting the value with other assets.
If you are the non-employee spouse, it’s critical that the order protects your right to information, notice of vesting, and payment when the asset becomes liquid. If you are the employee spouse, you need a clear, workable plan that won’t put you in violation of company policies or IRS rules.
Tax Implications and Hidden Traps
Many people overlook the tax bite. Stock options and executive awards can have significant tax consequences, depending on how and when they’re exercised or distributed. Failing to plan for capital gains, ordinary income, or alternative minimum tax can erode the value of your share.
A careful division plan should spell out:
- Who pays the taxes upon exercise or sale
- Whether withholding is required
- How net proceeds will be split
- What happens if the company is sold or reorganized
These issues are not hypothetical. Several North Carolina cases have involved years of post-divorce litigation because the original settlement left tax liability or distribution mechanics unclear.
Avoid Costly Mistakes in North Carolina Courtrooms
When the stakes include executive compensation or stock options, every detail counts—and so does the caliber of your legal team. Mercedes O. Chut, P.A. brings decades of experience and a hands-on approach to every family law case in Greensboro. If you are facing a divorce where stock options, RSUs, or executive compensation are in play, don’t wait until a mistake costs you thousands—or more. Schedule a confidential consultation now.
